Swartz + Associates
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Real Estate Tax Services
    • Personal Property Tax Services
    • Fixed Asset Valuations
  • Specialties
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu

Archive for category: General Information

Which One? Why the Purpose of an Appraisal Determines Equipment Value

October 26, 2026/in General Information/by Gary Stone

By Gary A. Stone, ASA, Manager at Swartz and Associates

Which One? Why the Purpose of an Appraisal Determines Equipment ValueMy last blog centered on how the manufacturing equipment industry is doing. I ended it with a question: “Which one?” This is also a question we ask when determining value.

Determining Scope

When a client hires us to provide appraisal services, we ask questions to determine the scope of the project. What type of equipment is being appraised? Is an inspection required? When is the appraisal due? What industry does our client operate in? And lastly, what is the purpose of the appraisal?

That last question is important because our clients depend on us to determine the appropriate type of value for the project. Most people outside the appraisal profession may not realize there are different ways to value machinery and equipment. The appropriate value depends on why the appraisal is being performed.

What is a CNC Lathe Worth?

As an example, we can take a large piece of manufacturing equipment, such as a CNC lathe. What is it worth?

NOTE: A CNC lathe is a computer-controlled machine tool that shapes material by rotating a workpiece against stationary cutting tools.

The value of a CNC lathe on the production floor, installed and fully operational, may be different from its value if it must be removed from the facility. Another factor to consider is how soon the machine needs to be sold. Is the seller in a hurry? The answers to these questions can determine a different value.

Fair Market Value

For example, mergers and acquisitions require a value that considers the equipment installed and operating as part of the business. In that situation, we use Fair Market Value—Installed or Fair Market Value in Continued Use. A bank is concerned with what the equipment will sell for if the borrower defaults. Therefore, we use Fair Market Value in Exchange and/or Orderly Liquidation Value when equipment serves as collateral for a loan. An auctioneer uses Forced Liquidation Value to estimate the amount the equipment would bring at an auction. Insurance companies require Replacement Cost because they need to cover the cost to replace their client’s equipment. A CPA firm and company management need Fair Value, as defined by Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) accounting standards, for financial reporting.

So, as you can see, “Which one?” is absolutely relevant when establishing the scope of work required in valuing equipment. Our clients depend on it.

Swartz + Associates, Inc. (SAI) is a full service property tax firm specializing in the review, analysis and appeals of real and business personal property tax valuations. If you could benefit from our expertise in appraisal services, please give us a call!

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Swartz-and-Associates-Equipment-Value-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Gary Stone https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Gary Stone2026-10-26 05:00:012026-10-01 12:08:17Which One? Why the Purpose of an Appraisal Determines Equipment Value

Could This Have Happened on a Teams Call? Probably Not.

October 19, 2026/in General Information/by Don Swartz

By Donald Swartz, President

Could This Have Happened on a Teams Call? Probably Not. Recently, I made the trip to St. Louis to see a long-time strategic partner. It had been more than a year since we last sat across the table from each other, and the timing finally lined up. We certainly talked business, but just as important, the visit gave us a chance to reconnect and keep strengthening a relationship that has served both of our organizations well for years.

That trip reminded me of something I believe has only become more true over time: you can never underestimate the power of connecting in person.

One Trip, Two Meetings

As I was heading to St. Louis, I reached out to one of our Indurante clients to see if they might be available for lunch while I was in town. We had met in person a few years earlier, and I was thrilled when they said yes. It’s not every year that I get to sit down face-to-face with a taxpayer we work with, so I was glad to make the most of it.

We started where good conversations usually start: catching up on the important things, which in this case meant family and sports. Only after that did the conversation drift toward business. And somewhere between the small talk and the check arriving, a new opportunity came up. The client mentioned a Kansas City facility, and that led to a conversation about having the Swartz team review property tax issues at the local level for that location.

Nobody walked into that lunch planning to discuss this new opportunity. It simply came up, the way things do when people are relaxed, attentive, and actually in the same room together.

Could It Have Happened on a Teams Call?

Possibly. If that Kansas City facility had been an agenda item, we certainly could have covered it on a phone call or a Teams meeting. Virtual tools are valuable, and we use them every day to serve clients efficiently across a wide geography.

But that is exactly the point. It was not on anyone’s agenda. Scheduled calls tend to stay on script: we cover the items, confirm next steps, and hang up. There is rarely room for the side comment that turns into a real conversation. In person, those openings happen naturally. The fact that this opportunity surfaced organically, over lunch, reinforces what I have long believed about the power of simply being there.

What In-Person Gives You That a Screen Cannot

Over the years, I’ve noticed a few things that face-to-face meetings consistently deliver:

  • Room for the unplanned. The best ideas and opportunities often come from tangents. In-person conversations leave space for them.
  • Deeper trust. Property tax work involves sensitive financial information and long-term decisions. Clients want to know the people behind the advice, and that trust builds faster when they can shake your hand.
  • Better listening. Without the distractions of a second monitor or an inbox pinging in the background, both sides are more present. You pick up on tone, body language, and the concerns people do not always say out loud.
  • A signal of commitment. Showing up takes time and effort, and people notice. Making the trip tells a partner or client that the relationship matters to you.
  • Relationships that last. A shared meal or conversation creates a personal connection that carries through every call and email that follows.

Making Face-to-Face Part of the Routine

In-person connection does not have to mean a special trip every time. Opportunities are all around us if we look for them:

  • Piggyback on travel. If you are already heading to a city for one meeting, reach out to other clients and partners in the area. That is exactly how my St. Louis lunch came together.
  • Show up at conferences and industry events. These gatherings put many of the people you work with in one place, often with built-in time to connect.
  • Keep it casual. A lunch, a cup of coffee, or an after-hours refreshment can do more for a relationship than a formal meeting ever could.
  • Put it on the calendar. For your most important relationships, plan an annual or periodic in-person visit so it does not keep getting pushed aside.
  • Let business come second. Go in to reconnect, not to pitch. When the relationship comes first, the business conversations tend to follow on their own.

Everyone Wins

Whether it is lunches, conferences or scheduled in-person events, it’s critical to recognize the value of the in-person relationship. It is easy to lose sight of this when virtual meetings are so convenient, but I have repeatedly seen the positive results when we make the effort. Clients feel better served, partnerships grow stronger, and new opportunities surface that might otherwise have stayed hidden. Everyone wins.

So if your situation allows, take the time to make face-to-face happen. Pick up the phone, suggest lunch, or add an extra stop to your next trip. I think you will be pleased with the results.

As always, please reach out to me at or . Better yet, let’s see if we can meet in person 😊

Swartz + Associates, Inc. (SAI) is a full service property tax firm specializing in the review, analysis and appeals of real and business personal property tax valuations. If you need help with your property taxes, give us a call!

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Swartz-and-Associates-The-importance-of-face-to-face-meetings-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Don Swartz https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Don Swartz2026-10-19 05:00:232026-09-28 15:46:41Could This Have Happened on a Teams Call? Probably Not.

Big‑Box Retail Assessments Are Rising Faster Than Market Values: It’s Costing Companies Millions

October 12, 2026/in General Information/by Eric Owens

By Eric Owens, Director at Swartz and Associates

Big‑Box Retail Assessments Are Rising Faster Than Market ValuesProperty tax assessments for big‑box retail are climbing 8–15% a year, even though market values aren’t. That gap is quietly eroding margins, and most companies don’t realize how fast it’s happening.

The core issue:

Assessors are valuing stores like thriving operating businesses instead of the real estate itself. When that happens, taxes rise on value that doesn’t exist.

Here are the biggest drivers:

  • County mass‑appraisal models ignore retail reality
    They miss declining foot traffic, functional obsolescence, excess parking, and dark‑store comparables. Assessments rise automatically, even when store performance doesn’t.
  • “Business value creep” inflates assessments
    Brand strength, sales performance, and tenant credit often get baked into valuation models — even though none of that is real estate value.
  • Remodels are treated like new construction
    Cosmetic upgrades, layout changes, and branding refreshes improve customer experience, not resale value. Yet many jurisdictions treat them as value‑adding improvements.

What companies can do:

  • Benchmark stores against dark‑store market values
  • Document functional obsolescence aggressively
  • Centralize appeal strategy across the portfolio

Bottom Line:

When assessments outpace market values, the issue isn’t the property,  it’s the valuation. Companies that treat property tax as a controllable expense consistently protect millions in operating margin, improve forecasting accuracy, and avoid paying for value that simply isn’t there. In a margin‑tight retail environment, getting the valuation right isn’t optional,  it’s one of the fastest ways to create immediate savings across a portfolio.

This is the work we focus on every day at Swartz & Associates: helping retailers correct overvaluations and regain control of their property tax exposure.

Swartz + Associates, Inc. (SAI) is a full service property tax firm specializing in the review, analysis and appeals of real and business personal property tax valuations. If you need help with your property taxes, give us a call!

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Swartz-and-Associates-Big-Box-Retail-Values-v2-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Eric Owens https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Eric Owens2026-10-12 05:00:372026-09-28 14:42:20Big‑Box Retail Assessments Are Rising Faster Than Market Values: It’s Costing Companies Millions

Beyond the Assessed Value: Lessons From IPT Property Tax School

October 5, 2026/in General Information/by Pacey Salzman

By Pacey Salzman, Client Research Specialist at Swartz and Associates

Beyond the Assessed Value: Lessons From IPT Property Tax SchoolAfter joining Swartz + Associates full time in August, I began training to become a property tax analyst. Attending the Institute for Professionals in Taxation (IPT) Property Tax School was an important step in that development, giving me the opportunity to strengthen my understanding of property taxation and the methods used to value property.

IPT’s Property Tax School provided me with a comprehensive foundation in the theory and practice of property taxation. The program covered topics including property tax administration, valuation principles, personal property attribution and valuation, tax research, and ethics. For me, the experience was an opportunity to take the concepts I encounter in my day-to-day work and better understand how they fit into the broader property tax process.

Understanding the Factors Behind Property Values

One of the most valuable parts of the program was taking a deeper look at property valuation. We explored the three primary approaches to value—the sales comparison, cost, and income approaches—and examined how each may be used to determine a property’s value.

Understanding these approaches is important when evaluating an assessment. Knowing how a value may have been developed makes it possible to review the underlying data more thoughtfully and identify questions or opportunities that may warrant further examination or a possible appeal.

Knowledge That Supports Our Clients

Because property tax practices vary significantly among jurisdictions, effective client support depends on careful research and close attention to local requirements. IPT Property Tax School strengthened my understanding of that complexity and showed me how professionals draw on technical knowledge, practical experience, and sound judgment when addressing property tax challenges.

Connecting Theory to Real-World Property Tax Work

Another important aspect of IPT Property Tax School was learning from professionals who work in the industry. The curriculum is taught by corporate, consulting, and legal practitioners, bringing different perspectives and real-world experiences into the classroom.

Hearing how experienced professionals approach valuation, tax research, administration, and other challenges helped me see how what I have learned working at Swartz + Associates fits within the broader property tax industry. Their examples also reinforced the importance of thorough research and attention to detail when working across different jurisdictions.

Continuing to Grow as a Property Tax Professional

My biggest takeaway was that property tax involves far more than reviewing an assessed value. The field brings together valuation theory, research, legislation and jurisdictional requirements, ethical considerations – all of which contribute to a well-informed analysis.

Attending IPT Property Tax School gave me a stronger foundation to build on as I continue developing my career. I’m looking forward to applying what I’ve learned to my work at Swartz + Associates and continuing to expand my understanding of the property tax industry.

Swartz + Associates, Inc. (SAI) is a full service property tax firm specializing in the review, analysis and appeals of real and business personal property tax valuations. If you need help with your property taxes, give us a call!

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Swartz-and-Associates-Lessons-from-IPT-Property-Tax-School-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Pacey Salzman https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Pacey Salzman2026-10-05 05:00:352026-09-28 13:24:04Beyond the Assessed Value: Lessons From IPT Property Tax School

Curiosity, Judgment, and Empathy: What AI Can’t Replace

September 28, 2026/in General Information/by Don Swartz

By Donald Swartz, President and Noelle Giacomino, Director at Indurante & Associates

Intro from Don

In July, I attended the 54th annual Property Tax Conference in Wichita, KS.  This is a “must attend” conference for Indurante & Associates. We meet with several assessors from various states and Departments of Revenue as well as clients/owners of private rail cars.

Since acquiring Indurante almost 8 years ago, I haven’t missed this conference (except for 2019) and the value it provides on a professional and social level continues to be valuable to Indurante. Noelle Giacomino was attending as well. We were talking about the event and her perspective, I thought her story was worth sharing, specifically how it relates to the trend of people adopting AI tools in their businesses.

Curiosity, Judgment, and Empathy: What AI Can't Replace

Thoughts from Noelle

Noelle GiacominoSeveral weeks ago, I traded the dry Las Vegas heat for Kansas humidity to attend the annual Wichita State Property Tax Conference.

The conference brings together property tax professionals from government agencies and the private sector, offering plenty of opportunities to:

  • Connect with colleagues from across the industry
  • Learn from informative educational sessions
  • Hear speakers explore current political and economic events, and what they mean for our field

For me, the daily keynote speakers are always a conference highlight. This year’s closing keynote featured Craig Karges, an entertainer, author, and nationally recognized speaker who blended magic, psychology, and intuition in ways that captivated the crowd. During his presentation, he also shared memory techniques designed to tap into the subconscious, spark creativity, and strengthen decision-making. Most importantly, Craig reminded the conference-goers that the human brain remains our most powerful tool.

Human Brains and AI in the Workplace

Curiosity, Judgment, and Empathy: What AI Can't ReplaceAfter watching Craig lift and move a table across the stage using only the tip of his finger, I left the session thinking about the power of the human mind in today’s artificial intelligence (AI) driven world. His presentation raised a question for me: How can I keep challenging myself and grow as a learner when AI is so accessible and makes many aspects of daily life easier?

I’m not sure there’s a straightforward answer to that question. However, I can accept that AI is here to stay and make a conscious effort to use it intentionally. Deciding when and how to use AI pushes me outside my comfort zone and encourages me to think critically about everyday tasks it can make more efficient.

Take this blog post, for example, AI helped me revise and edit it.

Writing doesn’t always come easily to me, and even with AI’s help, this post took longer to complete than I’d like to admit, but it would have taken much longer without it. In this case, AI freed up time for other pressing matters like responding to client emails.

Ultimately, AI is a tool, and using it well still depends on the human mind.

When we use AI thoughtfully, it can free up time for the work and activities that keep us engaged and help us grow. The goal isn’t to choose between human and artificial intelligence, but to use AI with intention while preserving curiosity, judgment, and empathy – qualities that remain uniquely human.

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Swartz-and-Associates-What-AI-Cannot-Replace-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Don Swartz https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Don Swartz2026-09-28 05:00:202026-09-03 14:18:45Curiosity, Judgment, and Empathy: What AI Can’t Replace

Texas vs. Arkansas: What Really Makes Commercial Property Values Different

September 21, 2026/in General Information/by Keith Sherman

By Keith Sherman, Business Development at Swartz and Associates

Texas vs. Arkansas: What Really Makes Commercial Property Values DifferentOver the last two and half years I’ve spent more time back in my home state of Arkansas, reconnecting with companies and introducing more of them to our value‑added commercial property tax services. At the same time, living in Plano has allowed me to pursue opportunities in Texas. Seeing both markets up close has made one thing very clear: the way commercial properties are valued and appealed in Texas and Arkansas is fundamentally different.

Those differences matter, especially for owners with multi‑state portfolios.

Arkansas: 20% Assessment + Reassessment Every 3–5 Years + Taxable Value Limits

Arkansas uses a simple statewide rule: Market Value × 20% = Assessed Value

Most counties reassess every 3–5 years, which keeps values stable and tax bills more predictable. But Arkansas adds another important layer: a cap on how much taxable value can increase each year.

Arkansas’ 10% Taxable Value Cap

State law limits annual increases in taxable value for commercial property to 10%, even in a reassessment year.

A simplified example:

  • 2026 market value: $10,000,000
  • 2026 assessed value: $2,000,000
  • 2026 taxable value: $2,000,000

If 2027 is a reassessment year and the market value rises to $15,000,000:

  • 2027 market value: $15,000,000
  • 2027 assessed value: $3,000,000
  • 2027 taxable value: $2,200,000 (only a 10% increase over 2026)

Because of the cap, the taxable value implies a market value of $11,000,000 ($2,200,000 ÷ 20%).

To actually reduce taxes, the owner must reduce the valuation below that implied value, not just below the reassessed number.

This cap creates a meaningful difference between assessed value and taxable value, especially in a reassessment year.

Texas: 100% Assessment + Annual Reassessment + Heavy Protest Culture

Texas appraisal districts start with full market value. A $10 million building is taxed on $10 million.

Texas also reassesses every year, which creates a highly active appeal environment. Because values reset annually, these protests can significantly change the taxable value, and the tax bill, every single year.

Bottom Line

Arkansas is built around stability with a 20% assessment ratio, infrequent reassessments, and a 10% cap on commercial taxable‑value increases.

Texas is built around annual valuation, full‑value taxation, and frequent protests.

For companies with property in both states, understanding these differences is essential to managing tax exposure and planning ahead.

Swartz + Associates, Inc. (SAI) is a full service property tax firm specializing in the review, analysis and appeals of real and business personal property tax valuations. If you need help with your property taxes, give us a call!

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Swartz-and-Associates-TX-vs-AR-Commercial-Property-Tax-Differences-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Keith Sherman https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Keith Sherman2026-09-21 05:00:182026-09-03 11:26:07Texas vs. Arkansas: What Really Makes Commercial Property Values Different

The 2026 World Cup Put Kansas City on the Map and Local Hotels Delivered

September 14, 2026/in General Information/by Charles Young

By Charles Young, Manager at Swartz and Associates

The 2026 World Cup Put Kansas City on the Map and Local Hotels DeliveredRegardless of your affinity for World Cup soccer, the 2026 tournament brought Kansas City unprecedented global exposure. And while every sector felt the impact, no industry anticipated — or ultimately experienced — a revenue surge quite like hospitality.

Hotel Demand: A Roller‑Coaster That Ended Strong

FIFA initially reserved massive blocks of hotel rooms across the metro to accommodate thousands of incoming fans. As match dates approached, roughly 75% of those reservations were canceled, creating early uncertainty for hoteliers.

But as match week approached, demand snapped back. Last‑minute bookings filled rooms, occupancy climbed, and average daily rate strengthened across the metro.

The Hotel & Lodging Association of Greater Kansas City divides the region into four key lodging zones, each experiencing its own World Cup story.

Downtown and Power & Light District

Highly sought‑after properties like the Crowne Plaza Kansas City Downtown approached full capacity on match days. Fans gravitated toward walkability, public transit access, and proximity to major viewing celebrations.

Crossroads Arts District

Boutique hotels such as Hotel Indigo Kansas City – The Crossroads saw heavy interest thanks to their arts‑scene location and seamless streetcar connectivity. Visitors loved the neighborhood’s creative energy and easy movement across the city.

Country Club Plaza

Upscale destinations like the InterContinental Kansas City at the Plaza enjoyed steady momentum that spiked sharply as match dates neared. Game‑specific crowds filled the Plaza’s restaurants, shops, and green spaces.

Suburban Communities

The 2026 World Cup Put Kansas City on the Map and Local Hotels DeliveredBudget‑minded and flexible travelers turned to outlying metro hotels as central‑city pricing surged. These suburban properties played a crucial role in absorbing overflow demand and keeping the region accessible for all types of visitors.

A City That Won Hearts

For those of us who love Kansas City, the best part wasn’t the numbers – it was the feedback.

Visitors praised the city’s hospitality, from the fan zone at Liberty Memorial to our legendary Kansas City BBQ. Media outlets spotlighted the friendliness, graciousness, and pride shown by residents who welcomed the world to town.

Kansas City didn’t just host the World Cup. We proved we belong on the global stage.

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Swartz-and-Associates-The-2026-World-Cup-Put-Kansas-City-on-the-Map-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Charles Young https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Charles Young2026-09-14 05:00:402026-08-31 11:21:16The 2026 World Cup Put Kansas City on the Map and Local Hotels Delivered

Used Manufacturing Equipment Market Update: What’s in Demand and What Isn’t

September 7, 2026/in General Information/by Gary Stone

By Gary A. Stone, ASA, Manager at Swartz and Associates

Used Manufacturing Equipment Market Update: What's in Demand and What Isn'tRecently, I had lunch with an associate who asked me, “How is the market?” My first response was, “Which one?” That led to a short conversation about the manufacturing industry and, ultimately, the topic for this blog. When it comes to used manufacturing equipment, there really isn’t one market. Demand can vary significantly depending on the type of equipment, industry, age, technology, and even the particular make and model.

Reshoring

Reshoring, the practice of bringing manufacturing operations or production back to the United States, is one factor influencing today’s manufacturing equipment market.

A recent Reshoring Initiative survey found increased reshoring activity among both original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) and contract manufacturers, with 63% of surveyed OEMs planning U.S. capital investment through 2027. The reasons extend beyond tariffs and geopolitical concerns. Manufacturers reported benefits from reshoring that included faster speed to market, improved delivery performance, and lower logistics costs. As manufacturers expand domestic capacity, this investment can create additional demand for machinery and equipment.

However, that demand is not evenly distributed. In the used CNC (Computer Numerical Control) market, certain 5-axis machining centers, multi-spindle turning centers, large horizontal machining centers, and wire EDM equipment are experiencing stronger demand, while more readily available 3-axis vertical machining centers, older CNC lathes, and CNC routers have faced softer market conditions.

Higher new equipment costs are also making quality used machinery an attractive alternative for manufacturers looking to add capacity. Buyers continue to place a premium on equipment that is productive, well maintained, supported, and easily integrated into their operations.

Used Manufacturing Equipment Market Update: What's in Demand and What Isn't Used Manufacturing Equipment Market Update: What's in Demand and What Isn't

Market Research

At Swartz + Associates, Inc., these trends reinforce why market research is such an important part of the appraisal process. Age and original cost provide useful information, but they don’t necessarily tell us what an asset is worth today. We also consider specifications, conditions, technological obsolescence, marketability, and what is actually occurring in the secondary market for that particular type of equipment.

As reshoring, technology, and capital investment continue to influence manufacturing, some equipment may benefit from increased demand while other equipment continues to depreciate.

If you’re trying to answer that question for your own equipment, whether you’re planning a sale, securing financing, settling an estate, or simply need to know what your assets are worth in today’s market, we can help. Swartz + Associates has been appraising machinery and equipment for many years, and our valuations are grounded in current market research, not just age and original cost. Give us a call or send us a note, and let’s talk about your equipment.

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Swartz-and-Associates-User-Manufacturing-Equipment-Market-Update-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Gary Stone https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Gary Stone2026-09-07 05:00:002026-09-03 10:59:48Used Manufacturing Equipment Market Update: What’s in Demand and What Isn’t

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America’s Great Northwest

August 31, 2026/in General Information/by Don Swartz

By Donald Swartz, President

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great NorthwestIf you have been a reader of my blog over the past 12 years (The Swartz Report), you may recall I would spend at least one blog per year on “road trips” with each of my children. These trips were either to take my kids back to college or to bring them home from college due to the Pandemic or graduation! Because they were school related, we made a point of stopping at various colleges or universities as part of our trips.

This year, I had the true pleasure of taking a road trip with my son for the sole purpose of site seeing; an 11-day adventure through South Dakota, Wyoming, Montana, a touch of Colorado and the exciting return through Nebraska. (My apologies to all my Husker friends but when you are ready to get home I-80 does not offer a lot of memories!!!)

An 11-Day Road Trip

  • Long hikes, visits to Custer State Park, Yellowstone National Park and Grand Teton National Park.
  • The Badlands, Devil’s Tower, Deadwood and Sturgis.
  • Golf stops in Windsor, CO and Nebraska City, NE (a different type of nature hike, but just as important 😉)
  • And, we still found time to visit multiple campuses as Aaron is a college counselor at a private high school (and it’s never a bad thing to visit schools in person when possible.) Creighton, South Dakota, Montana State, Wyoming and Colorado State were each graced with our presence during our trip, providing Aaron with additional insight for his students.

But most importantly, taking in nature and the vast “awesomeness” of the various national and state parks is absolutely breathtaking. To share the experience with an adult child is extra special.

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest

While I certainly remember traveling to Mt.  Rushmore, the Badlands and Wall Drug 50+ years ago with my family, I have a much greater appreciation for the beauty this country possesses. These landscapes provide perspective on what’s important in life. I believe Aaron shares the same feelings I have following our trip. It was a way to step back, put your phones and laptops away and just smell the roses. Or in this case, the bison, the elk, the bears, the lakes, the geysers and so much more.

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest

Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America's Great Northwest

 

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Swartz-and-Associates-Badlands-to-the-Tetons-11-Day-Road-Trip-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Don Swartz https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Don Swartz2026-08-31 05:00:302026-08-19 14:53:17Badlands to the Tetons: An 11-Day Road Trip Through America’s Great Northwest

The 7 Most Effective Strategies for Reducing Overvalued Big Box & Mid Box Retail Assessments

August 24, 2026/in General Information/by Eric Owens

By Eric Owens, Director at Swartz and Associates

The 7 Most Effective Strategies for Reducing Overvalued Big Box & Mid Box Retail AssessmentsIf you own or occupy big box or mid box retail, you already know the challenge: assessments often come in far above market reality. In my previous post about big box retail, I explained why this happens – outdated valuation models, contract‑rent reliance, misapplied comps, and low cap rates.

Now let’s talk about the part that matters most: How to actually win the appeal.

Across hundreds of retail appeals, these are the seven strategies that consistently move the needle.

1. Prove Market Rent – Not Contract Rent

Contract rent from a 10-20 year‑old lease is not market value.

Assessors respond when you show:

  • Second‑generation rent comps
  • Current asking rents for comparable boxes
  • Credit‑driven lease structures that inflate contract rent

When market rent is clearly lower, the valuation must follow.

2. Model Realistic Vacancy, Downtime & Absorption

Big box space doesn’t lease overnight.

Your appeal should include:

  • Typical downtime for 50,000-150,000 sq. ft. boxes
  • Absorption rates for second‑generation retail
  • Stabilized vacancy that reflects actual market conditions

Counties often underestimate downtime – correcting it can materially reduce value.

3. Quantify Functional & External Obsolescence

This is one of the most overlooked tools in retail appeals.

Show the assessor:

  • Retrofit costs
  • Ceiling height limitations
  • Loading and parking deficiencies
  • HVAC, roof, and mechanical mismatches
  • Neighborhood or trade‑area decline

Obsolescence isn’t theoretical – it’s measurable, and it directly impacts value.

4. Use the Right Comparable Sales

The comps that matter are:

  • Vacant or near‑vacant big box sales
  • Second‑generation transactions
  • Alternative‑use conversions (churches, gyms, storage, municipal)

Avoid:

  • Credit‑tenant sales
  • Build‑to‑suit deals
  • Portfolio allocations

Fee‑simple value comes from fee‑simple comps.

5. Support Cap Rates With Current Market Evidence

Retail cap rates have expanded – but many counties still use outdated cap rate studies which show lower capitalization rates.

Your appeal should include:

  • National retail cap rate surveys
  • Regional broker opinions
  • Local sales with verified cap rates
  • Adjustments for location, credit, and vacancy risk

A 100-200 bps correction can swing value dramatically.

6. Demonstrate the True Buyer Pool

Assessors often assume a credit‑tenant buyer.

But the real buyer pool for big box/mid box retail is:

  • Local investors
  • Value‑add buyers
  • Non‑retail users
  • Municipal or institutional repurposers

When you show who actually buys these assets, the valuation shifts to reality.

7. Present a Fee‑Simple Valuation – Not a Lease‑Driven One

This is the most important point.

Your appeal must clearly separate:

  • Fee‑simple value (what the real estate is worth)
  • Leased‑fee value (what the contract rent is worth)

Counties often blend the two. Your job is to unblend them – and show the correct standard.

The Bottom Line

Big box and mid box retail can be successfully appealed – often with meaningful reductions – when the evidence is presented clearly and tied to real market behavior.

Assessors aren’t trying to overvalue these assets. They’re using models that haven’t kept pace with today’s retail environment.

Your job is to bring them the data they’re missing.

If your retail portfolio hasn’t been reviewed recently, now is the time.

Swartz + Associates, Inc. (SAI) is a full service property tax firm specializing in the review, analysis and appeals of real and business personal property tax valuations. If you need help with your property taxes, give us a call!

https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Swartz-and-Associates-Reducing-Overvalued-Big-Box-Retail-Assessments-Featured-800x600-1.jpg 600 800 Eric Owens https://swartzandassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Swartz-and-Associates-logo.png Eric Owens2026-08-24 05:00:502026-07-30 12:56:42The 7 Most Effective Strategies for Reducing Overvalued Big Box & Mid Box Retail Assessments
Page 1 of 15123›»

Search

Search Search
© , All Rights Reserved, Swartz + Associates, Inc.
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
  • Specialties
  • Blog
  • Contact
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top